Wall Street is an exciting place to be, and sales and trading is one of Wall Street’s most exciting areas. If you’re a financial market junkie, then sales and trading might be right for you. Along with an interest in financial markets, it will help you break into the industry if you have a background in computational finance, software engineering, or another tech field. In recent years, there’s been a trend toward automated trading, some of which is done by using complex algorithms.
So what is sales and trading exactly? Many sales workers and traders work on the “sell side,” which refers to Wall Street investment banks that sell stocks, bonds, and other securities to the “buy side.” The buy side refers to the investment management firms, pension funds, hedge funds, and trusts that buy stocks, bonds, and other securities from the “sell side.” Outside the investment banking industry, traders work for hedge funds, brokerage firms, commercial banks, insurance companies, asset management firms, and mutual fund companies.
The most important function of a sales and trading department at an investment bank is, of course, to make money. An investment bank collects significant fees every time its sales and trading professionals execute a deal for clients. Traders and salespeople add incrementally to the bottom line through daily profits and losses and commissions, and raise the profile of the firm in the marketplace.
Opportunities for sales and trading professionals are available throughout the United States, but are best in New York City, where many investment banks, hedge funds, and other financial firms are located. Major investment banks include Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley, Centerview Partners, Evercore, and Credit Suisse. Leading hedge fund firms include Bridgewater Associates, AQR Capital Management, Man Group, Renaissance Technologies, Two Sigma, Millennium Management, Elliott Management, Baupost Group, BlackRock, and Winton Capital Management.
For years, an MBA was strongly preferred for those seeking trading positions. The increasing popularity of automated trading has changed the required skill set and educational background for traders. As an alternative to an MBA, employers are seeking traders with degrees in financial engineering, quantitative finance, software development, and related fields. Sales professionals need at least a bachelor’s degree in business, marketing, sales, quantitative finance, finance, accounting, or economics from a top-tier college.
Increasing regulation, calm financial markets (which are bad for trading and profit generation), and the increasing uses of automated trading and artificial intelligence have caused steep declines in the number of sales and trading professionals. In fact, more than 10,000 sales and trading positions were cut at the 10 largest investment banks from 2010 to 2015, according to the consulting firm Coalition Ltd. Despite this decline, there is still demand for traders who work with products that cannot easily be traded—such as illiquid products and bespoke over-the-counter financial products. Additionally, traders are needed to monitor automated trading systems to ensure that trading is conducted properly. There also will be strong demand for traders who can develop automated trading platforms (especially those that use artificial intelligence). Opportunities for sales professionals will be better because there will always be a need for sales workers to explain financial products and trading strategies to investors.
Sales and trading professionals earn high salaries—although they do not earn as much as they did before the Great Recession. Average compensation for equities sales, trading, and research professionals at the 12 largest global investment banks in the world totaled $500,000 (salary and bonus) in 2017, according to Coalition Ltd.
Theoretically, a good trader should be able to trade anything and a good salesperson should be able to sell anything. Still, a lot of thought does go into the product you end up trading or selling. Wall Street is constantly dreaming up new products to meet the needs of its clients. This process eventually creates a need for these firms to support the active trading of these products in the secondary market. Many products fit into several broad categories.Equity and Equity-Related Products
Equity markets provide a liquid market for the orderly trading of ownership interests (i.e., shares) in public companies. Shares are issued to investors who then have a stake in the company represented by a stock certificate. Listed or block trading involves all stocks traded on the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE), which prides itself on listing the biggest and best companies from around the world. The other major market for cash equities is the NASDAQ, which is home to both the best and the worst of the technology sector.Fixed Income Securities
Governments, corporations, agencies, organizations, supra-nationals, and financial institutions issue bonds to fund their activities. Bond market financing doesn’t represent an ownership stake, but rather an IOU with interest. Within this vast over-the-counter market, computers, telephones, and the Internet facilitate trading activity. Institutional customers call dealers who trade order flow (dealers whose goal is to provide liquidity for customers rather than trade on proprietary accounts) based on the real-time information that is continuously updated on these broker-maintained monitors.
Fixed income instruments can be traded as either negotiable or nonnegotiable. Non-negotiable loans are private transactions between two counterparties. Since these are private transactions, there’s not much need for traders or salespeople to get involved, so just know that this market category exists. The other major market segment is comprised of negotiable debt instruments, which trade on secondary markets after they have been issued by the borrower. These instruments include bonds and notes, and structured securities such as asset-backed and mortgage-backed securities. Negotiable fixed income instruments also include a class of instruments called derivatives, which derive value from an underlying market variable such as LIBOR (London Inter-bank Offered Rate).
Another way of segmenting the bond market is to broadly divide the universe of fixed income products into two groups: government bonds and spread products. Government bonds are issued by the U.S. Treasury and are the risk-free standard backed by the full faith and credit of the United States government. Spread products are bonds issued by any other issuer-agencies, corporations, foreign governments, and supra-national organizations. Spread products have additional default risk, and are quoted as a “spread over comparable Treasuries” that is, the difference in yield when compared to a treasury board of the same term. For example, if a 10-year U.S. Treasury bond offers a 3% yield and a 10-year IBM bond offers a 3.5% yield, the spread is 0.5%.Government Bonds
U.S. Treasuries are the benchmark against which all other fixed-income products are priced. If you enjoyed economics in college, this might be a great product area for you. Government bond desks are organized by maturity. “Treasury bills” are government bonds with a maturity of one year or less. The Treasury issues three-month, six-month, and one-year Treasury bills, which are discount securities that pay par at maturity. (The bills pay a set amount a bit above the original purchase price; this amount is called the par value of the security.) “Treasury notes” are securities that have a maturity exceeding one year, but not exceeding 10 years. “Treasury bonds” (10- and 30-year bonds) are the longest-dated maturity instruments issued by the Treasury. Notes and bonds are both conventional semi-annual coupon-paying securities. The Treasury also issues STRIPS (Separate Trading of Registered Interest and Principal of Securities), or zero-coupon bonds. These securities allow investors to hold and to trade the individual interest and principal components of eligible Treasury notes and bonds as separate securities. Another Treasury product are TIPS (Treasury Inflation Protected Securities), which pay interest based on the level of inflation.
The shortest maturity products are like trading with training wheels. It’s tough to screw up if you’re a three-month bill trader or repo trader. (Repo and reverse repo are the business of borrowing and lending securities.) The seasoned veterans are on the long end of the curve, trading 10- and 30-year bonds. These instruments have the most price volatility for a given change in yield. Long-dated zero coupons are the most price volatile instruments in the government bond market, since the full value of the bond is received as a bullet at maturity.
While U.S. government bonds do not have any default risk, do not mistake this for meaning that bonds are risk-free investments. Even with the full faith and credit of the U.S. Treasury, govies are interest-rate sensitive, and the principal can fluctuate dramatically in different interest rate environments. However, for buy-and-hold investors, there is no interest rate risk, since the principal is fully returned at maturity.Agency Bonds
Federal government agencies issue bonds to finance their activities. These agency bonds help support projects relevant to public policy, such as farming, small business, or loans to first-time home buyers. Agency bonds do not carry the full faith-and-credit guarantee of government-issued bonds, but they carry triple-A ratings due to the implicit guarantee that exists between the government and a government agency. This implicit guarantee allows the respective government agency to access low-cost capital to support objectives deemed to be consistent with the national interest. Federal agencies that issue bonds include:
- Federal National Mortgage Association (Fannie Mae)
- Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation (Freddie Mac)
- Farm Credit System
- Federal Agricultural Mortgage Corporation (Farmer Mac)
- Federal Home Loan Banks
- Small Business Administration
- Tennessee Valley Authority
Corporate bonds are bonds issued by corporations to meet their short- and long-term working capital requirements. “Non-dollar corporate bonds” are issued in currencies other than the U.S. dollar. Secondary trading activities tend to be most robust at dealers that have strong deal flow and a reputable credit research department. These research departments are always analyzing prospective bond swaps and are searching for favorable relative value trades (e.g., swapping down in credit or within similarly rated paper for a pick-up in yield, or swapping up in credit for a minimal yield give-up).
Corporate bonds are typically divided into two markets: high grade and high yield. Whether a bond is high grade or high yield depends on credit ratings given to the company by credit rating agencies like Standard & Poor’s and Moody’s. The higher the credit rating, the lower the risk of default, and the lower the interest. High grade bonds are issued by companies with good credit ratings and offer a lower yield (interest) for investors. High yield bonds (also known as “junk bonds”) are any issues that trade below BBB from Standard & Poor’s and Baa from Moody’s. Sometimes, in anticipation of a credit downgrade, high grade bonds can trade with spreads equivalent to high yield bonds and vice versa.International Bonds
International bond markets are less regulated than domestic bond markets, and therefore carry greater default risk. Anytime an investor buys bonds outside of his local currency, he or she is also incurring foreign currency risk (the currency invested in can drop relative to the dollar), and in certain emerging markets, there is the added dimension of political risk (a coup will make bonds issued from that country lose their value quickly). There are four main types of international bonds issued by corporations, governments, sovereigns, and supranationals: foreign bonds, eurobonds, dragon bonds, and global bonds.
1. Foreign bonds are issued by foreign borrowers in a domestic market denominated in that market’s own currency. The domestic market authorities regulate the issuance of these bonds. An example of a foreign bond would be IBM (an American company) issuing bonds in the United Kingdom, or SAP (a German company) issuing bonds in the United States. IBM issuing bonds in the United Kingdom would be a Bulldog issue, and SAP issuing bonds in the United States would be a Yankee issue.
2. Eurobonds are instruments for unsecured debt issued by governments, banks, corporations, and supranationals that are outside the domestic market of the currency of denomination. Eurobonds are sold to an international group of investors who are beneficial owners of the currency of issue but not resident in the country of that currency. This last attribute means that Eurobonds enjoy a less restrictive regulatory environment, since they are not subject to national laws or regulations. A further advantage of Eurobonds is that they can be issued in any country and in any currency other than that of its country of issue, affording maximum flexibility to the issuer. The historical unofficial home of Eurobond trading is the United Kingdom.
3. Dragon bonds are issued in any currency and trade on at least two of the “Dragon” exchanges in Asia (except those in Japan)—including Hong Kong, Singapore, or Taiwan. They are relatively short-term (three to five years).
4. Global bonds are traded simultaneously in the Eurobond market and on one or more domestic markets. Global bond issuers are typically triple-A rated and are frequently accessing the capital markets.Municipal Bonds
Municipal bonds are issued by local and state governments. Typically, these securities are tax-exempt, and therefore trade at lower yields. Investors need to consider their individual tax brackets to consider the relative attractiveness of municipal bonds relative to comparable taxable bonds. Municipal bonds are favored by wealthy investors in higher tax brackets. Municipal bonds (or "munis") are categorized as general obligation or revenue bonds. General obligation bonds are supported by the taxing power of the issuer, and revenue bonds are secured by revenues from tolls and rents for a range of projects and facilities.Asset-Backed Securities
Asset-backed securities include any products that are secured by some type of asset. These products include securities collateralized by mortgages (mortgage-backed securities), credit cards, aircraft loans, and so on.Mortgage Securities
Mortgage securities represent an ownership interest in mortgage loans made by financial institutions to finance the borrower’s purchase of a home or other real estate. Mortgage securities are created when these loans are pooled by issuers or servicers for sale to investors. Two particular types of mortgage securities are worth knowing about.Pass-Throughs or Participation Certificate
The issuer or servicer of pass-through securities collects the monthly mortgage payment from homeowners whose loans are in a given pool (a pool brings together loans of the same maturity and same coupon rate) and “passes through” the cash flow to investors in monthly payments. Most pass-through securities are backed by fixed-rate mortgages, but adjustable-rate mortgages are also pooled to create pass-through securities. ARMS typically have caps and floors. These option-like characteristics require a higher yield on the ARM-backed pass-through security.Real Estate Mortgage Investment Conduit (REMIC)/Collateralized Mortgage Obligation
Mortgage-backed-securities collateralized by mortgage pass-through securities. REMICs allow cash flows to be directed so that different classes of securities with different maturities and coupons can be created.Convertible Securities Convertible Bond Basics
Convertibles combine the equity upside with the income characteristics of bonds. Convertible bond desks offer a nice work environment for people with an analytical bent who want something a little more exciting than bonds.
Here’s a basic example of how a convertible bond might be structured: convertible bonds of Company X can be converted into five shares of Company X stock if its stock price rises above a pre-specified threshold. There are three determinants of value in a convertible bond: investment value, conversion value, and option value. Investment value refers to the value of the convertible bond if it were a straight bond. This is the value below which a convertible can never trade. The conversion value is the value of the bond if it were to be converted into stock of Company X. In this case, if Company X stock currently trades at $20/share, and converting one bond for five bonds produces a conversion value of $100. If the conversion value exceeds the investment value, then conversion value takes precedence. Note that conversion value can only be positive since it is a right and not an obligation available to convertible bond investors. This option normally translates into a convertible bond price that exceeds the investment and conversion value. The present value of this premium represents the option value of the convert.Convertible Arbitrage Trade Example
This transaction type consists of matching a long position in a convertible security (owning the security) with an offsetting short position (owning the right to sell at a certain price) in the underlying stock. The main driver of profitability in convertible arbitrage transactions is the current income generated by combining the yield of the convertible security with the interest income on the proceeds from the short positions, less any dividends on the shares sold short.
Additional profit is generated through delta hedging. First, the setup: suppose the price of a convertible bond is $1,000, and that the company’s current stock price is $75 with a 33% conversion premium, so the value of the stock conversion premium is $100. Option delta is the change in the price of the option for a 1% increase in the stock option. Assuming an option delta of 0.5, then the amount of shares to sell short is given by the following formula:
Hedge ratio = (Convertible bond price/Conversion premium) * Option delta = ($1000/$100) * 0.5 = 5 shares
The hedge ratio indicates that for every one convertible bond owned, five shares should be sold short. For small changes in the price of the stock, this delta hedge creates a market-neutral position where the profit from this convertible arbitrage trade is the income from the short and the coupon on the bond. In volatile markets, this hedge breaks down and a large decrease in the value of the stock will create an additional profit, since the stock will lose more in value than the convertible. Similarly, if the price of the stock increases substantially, the convertible will gain more than the short stock position, again earning a profit for the convertible arbitrage trader. Typically, the bond side of the trade needs to be hedged, since if the yield curve shifts significantly, the trader could end up reaping an additional windfall gain or loss, which is not part of the game for most convertible arb trades.Derivatives
A derivative is an agreement between two parties in which each agrees to transfer an asset or amount of money on or before a specified future date at a specified price. A derivative’s value is derived from one or more underlying variables. Originally, derivatives trading involved commodities as a way for farmers to hedge away the financial risk of their business, but today derivatives are tied to everything from currencies and interest rates to the weather.
- A forward contract is a transaction in which the buyer and seller agree upon the delivery of a specified quality and quantity of asset at a specified future date. A price is normally specified in advance or at the time of delivery.
- A futures contract is a legally binding obligation for the holder of the contract to buy or sell a particular commodity at a specific price and location at a specific date in the future. The appeal of an exchange-traded future is that the contracts can be standardized, so that everyone in the market is trading the same contract.
- An option gives the buyer the right, but not the obligation, to buy (call) or sell (put) the underlying asset at a specified price (called the “strike price”) up to or on a specific future date (expiration date). The buyer of the option pays the seller of the option a premium for this right.
- A swap is the simultaneous buying and selling of a similar asset or obligation of equivalent capital amount. This exchange of financial arrangements provides both parties with more favorable conditions than they would otherwise expect. For example, a payer of fixed-rate debt may desire paying floating-rate debt, and a payer of floating-rate debt may want to pay fixed-rate debt. If the two sides can agree on a notional amount upon which to compute coupon payments, then they can swap fixed for floating and floating for fixed. The notional amount never changes hands, and interest payments are netted.
The main reason for using derivatives is to manage risk. The derivatives market offers hedgers like the chief financial officer of a large industrial company a way to hedge away his firm’s financial risk, and it provides speculators (who are hopelessly addicted to leverage) an opportunity to profit from a particular market view. Arbitrageurs keep the market efficient by exploiting any price discrepancies between different markets or between the derivative and the underlying asset. Derivatives can trade in three ways, explained in the following sections.Fixed Income Derivatives
Fixed income derivatives are any derivatives instruments which derive value from a fixed-income security. Typically, these instruments are structured by Wall Street firms as a way to reallocate risks from corporations (who are seeking to mitigate business or financial risk) to speculators (who are seeking risk exposure in the expectation of profiting from a particular market view). Dealers will create a derivative instrument, and to support the development of this market will subsequently engage in creating and maintaining an active secondary market. As the market becomes more developed, spreads that the dealers pocket decrease dramatically. When interest rate swaps were popularized by Bankers Trust, it was able to extort exorbitant fees from relatively unsophisticated corporate treasurers. One word of caution for the neophyte fixed income derivative enthusiast: Warren Buffet has characterized derivatives as “financial weapons of mass destruction.” While Wall Street has peddled derivatives as an efficient manner of reallocating risk, as the Long Term Capital Management debacle demonstrated, there are tremendous amounts of counter-party risk, since risk ends up being concentrated in relatively few hands, and one default in the derivatives market can trigger multiple defaults throughout the system, threatening the integrity of the entire worldwide financial market.Equity Derivatives
Equity derivatives trade listed and OTC equity options. OTC options are contracts structured by the firm to meet the needs of specific institutional customers. Listed options are exchange-listed products that are completely standardized and more liquid. Call holders have the right (but not the obligation) to purchase shares of the underlying company at a pre-specified price. Put holders have the right to sell shares of the underlying company at a pre-specified price. Dealers are typically sellers of options, and the vast majority of options expire worthless (out-of-the-money). Being short options is equivalent to being short volatility (some options desks now call themselves “volatility trading desks”). Options give the right to buy or sell an underlying stock: the higher the volatility, the greater the price of the option; the lower the volatility, the lower the price of the option. When a desk is net short options, it is short volatility, and will profit if volatility does not exceed the implied volatility at which the options were sold at. Think of options desks as insurers who are constantly collecting small premiums, but must, every once in a while, make a large payout related to a natural or manmade disaster.Over-the-Counter (OTC) Derivatives
Dealers structure and trade just about anything that can generate a fee, but typically these structured products compete with standardized exchange-traded products. These products include currency and commodity derivatives, as well as interest rate swaps. Structured products like interest rate swaps will typically trade over-the-counter, whereas more standardized products are traded on exchanges such as the Chicago Board of Trade and the London International Financial Futures and Options Exchange.
By now you should understand that the OTC equity market, the OTC bond market, and the OTC derivatives market are all inter-dealer markets connected by telephone and computer network. There is no centralized exchange floor.
- Exciting work environment. The trading floor is fast-paced, and sales workers get the chance to interact with a wide range of clients.
- Good hours for traders. Unlike some of their investment banking and hedge fund colleagues, traders have more reasonable hours. They arrive to work prior to market open (6 a.m. to 7 a.m.), and then can leave when their particular market closes in the late afternoon. They do not have to work on weekends.
- Good pay. Associates in equity cash sales and trading careers can make $200,000 to $250,000 a year, according to the Options Group, an executive search firm. Sales and trading managing directors can receive up to $1 million in total compensation.
- A rewarding career. A career in sales or trading can be extremely fulfilling for those who are interested in the financial industry and using their knowledge to make money for both themselves and their clients. Sales workers enjoy researching and suggesting trading strategies to customers, and find it rewarding when their suggestions are profitable.
- Many potential career paths.Skilled and experienced sales and trading professionals can either advance to managerial positions at their firms or move on to work at private equity, hedge fund, or financial consulting firms, or they can launch their own businesses. If you decide to exit sales or trading, you can transition to work at a financial regulator, move into risk management in the middle office, or work in management or financial consulting.
- Intellectually rewarding. The vast range of financial products and trading strategies, as well as the fast pace of trading, will keep you from getting bored. You’ll also need to continually learn in order to understand new financial products and trading systems.
- Automation. Many traders have lost their jobs as a result of the shift to electronic trading. As a result, it’s much harder to get a job in the field—especially if you do not have a degree from a top university.
- The work week for sales professionals can be long. You must be available at night and on weekends to “wine and dine” potential and existing clients. Requests from clients can interrupt vacations and family time.
- Lack of geographic freedom. Job opportunities are centered in New York City, London, Chicago, Dubai, and other financial centers. If you don’t already live in one of these cities, you may have to move to land a job.
- Stressful work environment. With so much money on the line, traders have to make split-second trading decisions—and this can be extremely stressful. Sales workers face steady competition for new clients, and they must work very hard to keep sometimes difficult current clients happy.
- Diversity issues. Some investment banks, hedge funds, and other firms that employ sales and trading professionals have a reputation of being unfriendly to women and minorities. This is changing as a result of the #MeToo and other social justice movements, but firms have a long way to go before the percentage of women and minority sales and trading professionals matches their percentage in the U.S. population. Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley, Credit Suisse, Deutsche Bank, and other large firms have launched diversity programs, but most people agree that more can be done.